refactored-recon/NAVI-DIRECTIONS-REDESIGN.md

Navi Directions UX Redesign

Status: Draft Author: Claude + Matt Date: 2026-04-26 Implementation: Deferred to dedicated session

---

1. Current State

Components

Component	File	Role
SearchBar	SearchBar.jsx	Overloaded: search, add stop, set origin (hidden modes)
StopList	StopList.jsx	Drag-drop reordering of stops
GpsOriginItem	GpsOriginItem.jsx	"Your location" row when GPS granted
StopItem	StopItem.jsx	Individual stop with delete button
ModeSelector	ModeSelector.jsx	auto/pedestrian/bicycle toggle
ManeuverList	ManeuverList.jsx	Turn-by-turn directions display
PlaceDetail	PlaceDetail.jsx	"Directions" button for selected place

State Model

stops: []                    // Array of {id, lat, lon, name, source, matchCode}
gpsOrigin: true              // Use GPS as origin when available
pendingDestination: null     // Place waiting for origin (GPS-denied flow)
route: null                  // Valhalla trip response
routeLoading: false
routeError: null

Failure Modes

1. No visible from/to inputs — Users cannot see or directly edit origin/destination
2. SearchBar hidden mode-switching — Three different behaviors based on invisible state:
   • Normal: opens place detail
   • With pendingDestination: first result becomes origin
   • After adding stops: unclear which role next selection plays
3. GPS-denied flow uses ephemeral toast — "Set a starting point" disappears, no persistent UI guidance
4. No swap button — Cannot reverse route direction
5. No map context menu — Right-click/long-press does nothing
6. No waypoint addition UI — Only drag-drop reordering, no insert-between
7. Place panel "Directions" silently sets up route — Based on hidden state, no confirmation

---

2. Design Principles

1. Direct manipulation over hidden modes — Every action should have visible UI
2. Two visible inputs always — When in directions mode, From and To fields are always visible
3. Spatial interactions over linear — Radial menu for map interactions, not dropdowns
4. Same gesture model everywhere — Right-click (desktop) = long-press (mobile)
5. Preserve existing state model — stops[] array stays, just better UI on top

---

3. Visual Mockup — Directions Panel

┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│  DIRECTIONS                         │
├─────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                     │
│  From: [📍 Your location      ][×]  │
│         ────────────────────────    │
│                    [⇅]              │  ← Swap button
│         ────────────────────────    │
│  To:   [Coffee shop on Main St][×]  │
│                                     │
│  [+ Add stop]                       │
│                                     │
├─────────────────────────────────────┤
│  [🚗 Auto] [🚶 Walk] [🚲 Bike]      │
├─────────────────────────────────────┤
│  ┌─────────────────────────────┐    │
│  │ 12 min · 4.2 mi             │    │
│  │ via W Main St               │    │
│  └─────────────────────────────┘    │
│                                     │
│  ▼ Turn-by-turn (expandable)        │
│    → Head north on Oak Ave          │
│    ↱ Turn right onto Main St        │
│    ◉ Arrive at destination          │
│                                     │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘

Input States

From field:

• GPS granted: Shows "📍 Your location" pill with clear button
• GPS denied/cleared: Empty, placeholder "Starting point..."
• Filled: Shows place name with clear button

To field:

• Empty: Placeholder "Destination..."
• Filled: Shows place name with clear button

Active input:

• Blue border highlight
• Search dropdown appears on typing
• Map click populates this field

---

4. Visual Mockup — Radial Map Menu

                    Drop pin
                      🔴
                    ╱    ╲
                  ╱        ╲
    Directions  ╱            ╲  Directions
    from here 🟢──────────────🔵 to here
              │   43.6166    │
              │  -116.2008   │
              │  [loading…]  │  ← Center disc with coords/label
    Add as   🟡──────────────🟣 Save place
    stop       ╲            ╱
                 ╲        ╱
                   ╲    ╱
                    🟠
                 What's here

Wedge Layout (60° each)

Position	Action	Icon	Color
Top	Drop pin	Pin	Red
Top-right	Directions to here	Arrow-in	Blue
Bottom-right	Save place	Star	Purple
Bottom	What's here	Info	Orange
Bottom-left	Add as stop	Plus	Yellow
Top-left	Directions from here	Arrow-out	Green

Behavior

• Trigger: Right-click (desktop) or long-press 400-500ms (mobile)
• Center disc: ~40px diameter, shows coordinates immediately, reverse-geocoded label async
• Wedge highlight: On hover (desktop) or drag-over (mobile)
• Commit: Release on wedge (mobile) or click wedge (desktop)
• Cancel: Release outside, Escape key, tap elsewhere

---

5. Component Breakdown

DirectionsPanel

Replaces current Panel directions mode.

Props: none (reads from store)
State: none (all in global store)
Children:
  - LocationInput (from)
  - SwapButton
  - LocationInput (to)
  - WaypointList (if stops.length > 2)
  - AddStopButton
  - ModeSelector
  - RouteSummary
  - ManeuverList (collapsible)

LocationInput

Reusable component for from, to, and waypoint inputs.

Props:
  - slot: 'from' | 'to' | `waypoint:${index}`
  - value: { lat, lon, name, source } | null
  - placeholder: string
  - showGpsPill: boolean
  - onClear: () => void

Features:
  - Search-as-you-type (Photon geocoder)
  - GPS pill state with clear button
  - Active-input visual state (blue border)
  - Reverse-geocoded labels for coord-only entries
  - Dropdown for search results

SwapButton

Simple button between From and To inputs.

Props: none
Action: Swaps stops[0] and stops[stops.length - 1]
Visual: ⇅ icon, hover highlight

WaypointList

Refactored from existing StopList, preserves drag-drop.

Props: none (reads stops from store)
Features:
  - Only renders stops[1..n-1] (middle waypoints)
  - Drag-drop reordering via @dnd-kit
  - Delete button per waypoint
  - "Via" label prefix

RadialMenu

New general-purpose component.

Props:
  - open: boolean
  - x: number (screen X)
  - y: number (screen Y)
  - lat: number
  - lon: number
  - wedges: Array<{ id, icon, label, action: (lat, lon) => void }>
  - onClose: () => void

Features:
  - Configurable wedge count and actions
  - Async center label (reverse geocode)
  - Keyboard dismissal (Escape)
  - Touch-friendly sizing on mobile
  - Fade in/out animations

---

6. State Model

Existing (unchanged)

stops: []              // Origin = stops[0], destination = stops[last], waypoints in between
gpsOrigin: boolean     // Whether GPS should be used as origin
route: object | null   // Valhalla trip response
routeLoading: boolean
routeError: string | null

New

activeInputSlot: 'from' | 'to' | `waypoint:${N}` | null
// Which input is currently focused/active for map-click-to-fill

radialMenuState: {
  open: boolean,
  x: number,           // Screen coordinates
  y: number,
  lat: number,         // Map coordinates
  lon: number,
  label: string | null // Reverse-geocoded, async populated
}

Removed

pendingDestination: null  // No longer needed — explicit inputs replace hidden state

---

7. Interaction Flows

Open directions tab fresh

1. From field shows GPS pill if geoPermission === 'granted', else empty
2. To field is empty, focused by default
3. No route calculated yet

Click "Directions" from place panel

1. Directions panel opens (if not already)
2. To field auto-fills with selected place
3. From field:
   • If GPS granted: shows GPS pill
   • Else: empty, receives focus
4. Route calculates if both filled

Type in input

1. Input receives focus, becomes activeInputSlot
2. Photon search fires on debounce (300ms)
3. Dropdown shows results
4. Select result → populates input, clears dropdown
5. Route recalculates

Right-click / long-press on map

1. Radial menu appears centered on click point
2. Center disc shows coordinates immediately
3. Reverse geocode fires async, populates label
4. User hovers/drags to wedge:

Wedge	Action
Directions from here	Opens directions if closed, fills From with coords, focuses To
Directions to here	Opens directions if closed, fills To with coords, focuses From if empty
Add as stop	Inserts new stop before destination
What's here	Reverse geocode → opens place panel
Drop pin	Creates transient marker (session-only)
Save place	Opens save dialog (auth required)

5. Release outside or Escape → dismisses without action

Click map with active input

When directions panel is open and an input is focused (activeInputSlot !== null):

1. Single click on map
2. Clicked coordinates populate the active input
3. Reverse geocode fires to get display name
4. Input loses focus, activeInputSlot = null
5. Route recalculates

Swap button

1. Click swap button
2. stops[0] and stops[stops.length - 1] swap positions
3. If GPS was origin, GPS pill moves to destination (unusual but allowed)
4. Route recalculates

---

8. Place Panel "Directions" Handoff

Current behavior: Calls startDirections(place) with complex conditional logic, may show toast.

New behavior:

handleDirections = () => {
  // Always open directions panel
  setActiveTab('directions')

  // Fill destination
  setStop(stops.length, {  // Appends or replaces last
    lat: place.lat,
    lon: place.lon,
    name: place.name,
    source: place.source
  })

  // Handle origin
  if (geoPermission === 'granted') {
    setGpsOrigin(true)  // GPS pill in From
  } else if (stops.length === 0) {
    setActiveInputSlot('from')  // Focus From input
  }

  // Close place panel
  clearSelectedPlace()
}

No toast needed — UI is self-explanatory with visible From/To fields.

---

9. Radial Menu Specifics

Trigger

Platform	Gesture	Duration
Desktop	Right-click	Instant
Mobile	Long-press	400-500ms

Conflict Avoidance

Long-press must NOT fire during active pan:

• Track touch start position
• If touch moves >5px before timer fires, cancel long-press
• Pan gesture takes priority

Geometry

Outer radius: ~80px from center
Inner radius: ~40px (center disc)
Wedge angle: 60° each (6 wedges)
Gap between wedges: 2px

Visual States

Element	Default	Hover/Active	Selected
Wedge background	rgba(0,0,0,0.7)	rgba(0,0,0,0.85)	Wedge accent color
Wedge icon	White, 50% opacity	White, 100% opacity	White
Wedge label	Hidden	Shown (tooltip)	Shown
Center disc	Dark, coords visible	—	—

Animation

• Fade in: <100ms ease-out
• Fade out: <150ms ease-in
• Wedge hover: Instant background change
• Center label: Fade in when reverse geocode completes

---

10. Mobile Considerations

Panel Layout

Decision needed: Bottom sheet vs side panel

Option	Pros	Cons
Bottom sheet	Familiar (Google Maps), thumb-friendly	Complex sheet state management
Side panel	Consistent with desktop, more vertical space	Covers more map, less thumb-friendly

Recommendation: Bottom sheet with three states: collapsed (summary only), half (inputs + summary), full (inputs + maneuvers).

Long-press Timing

Decision needed: Exact timing

Duration	Feel
400ms	Snappy, risk of accidental trigger
450ms	Balanced
500ms	Deliberate, slightly sluggish

Recommendation: Start with 450ms, tune based on testing.

Radial Sizing

Mobile radial should be larger for finger touch:

• Outer radius: ~100px (vs 80px desktop)
• Center disc: ~50px (vs 40px desktop)
• Minimum wedge touch target: 48px

Compact Directions Mode

When route is calculated and user is navigating:

1. Collapse From/To inputs to single-line summary
2. Show prominent next maneuver
3. Expand on tap to edit inputs
4. Maneuver list scrollable

Keyboard Awareness

• Detect keyboard open via visualViewport API
• Shift panel content up to keep active input visible
• Don't let keyboard overlap input being typed in

---

11. Place Panel Restructure

Out of scope for this document.

Separate session will address:

• Cleaner info card layout (Google Maps style)
• Better visual hierarchy
• Action button placement
• No new data sources, just CSS/JSX polish

---

12. Out of Scope (Future Phases)

Feature	Notes
Saved routes	Auth required, dedicated work
Route alternatives	Valhalla supports, surface in v2
Avoid tolls/highways	Valhalla supports via costing options
Real-time rerouting	Requires location tracking loop
Multi-modal	Drive + transit + walk hybrids
Traffic-aware routing	Requires traffic data source
Offline routing	Requires local Valhalla instance

---

13. Implementation Sequence

Phase	Task	Depends On
a	Build RadialMenu component (general-purpose, no actions wired)	—
b	Wire "What's here" action to validate trigger + reverse-geocode flow	a
c	Refactor SearchBar to single-mode (search-only, remove pending* logic)	—
d	Build LocationInput component (reusable)	c
e	Build DirectionsPanel layout with two LocationInputs	d
f	Wire remaining radial actions to directions flow	b, e
g	Wire place panel "Directions" handoff to new flow	e
h	Add SwapButton	e
i	Add map-click-to-fill-active-input	e
j	Mobile polish (long-press timing, bottom sheet, keyboard)	a-i

Estimated phases: 10 discrete tasks, can be done incrementally.

---

14. Open Questions

For Matt to decide:

1. Bottom sheet vs side panel on mobile?

   • Bottom sheet recommended but adds complexity

2. Long-press timing exactly?

   • 400ms / 450ms / 500ms
   • Recommend 450ms

3. Should "Save place" wedge be visible to guests or hidden?

   • Visible with login prompt = more discoverable
   • Hidden = cleaner for guests
   • Recommend: visible, shows "Sign in to save" toast

4. Inner ring of secondary actions in radial v2?

   • Could add less-common actions in inner ring
   • Recommend: stay single-ring for v1, evaluate need later

5. What does "Drop pin" persistence look like?

   • Session only (lost on refresh)
   • localStorage (persists locally)
   • Auth-only saved (sync across devices)
   • Recommend: session-only for v1, localStorage for v2

6. Radial on map click during active input?

   • Option A: No radial, click fills input directly
   • Option B: Radial appears, "Use this location" wedge fills input
   • Recommend: Option A (direct fill) for simplicity

---

Appendix A: Current Code References

File	Lines	Relevance
store.js	72-86	startDirections() logic to replace
store.js	16-34	stops[] management to preserve
SearchBar.jsx	140-170	pendingDestination logic to remove
PlaceDetail.jsx	574-579	handleDirections() to rewrite
App.jsx	31-66	Route fetch effect to preserve
api.js	29-56	requestRoute() unchanged

---

Appendix B: Radial Menu SVG Structure

<svg viewBox="0 0 200 200">
  <!-- Wedge paths -->
  <g class="wedges">
    <path d="M100,100 L100,20 A80,80 0 0,1 169,60 Z" class="wedge" data-action="drop-pin" />
    <path d="M100,100 L169,60 A80,80 0 0,1 169,140 Z" class="wedge" data-action="to-here" />
    <!-- ... 4 more wedges ... -->
  </g>

  <!-- Center disc -->
  <circle cx="100" cy="100" r="40" class="center-disc" />
  <text x="100" y="95" class="coords">43.6166</text>
  <text x="100" y="110" class="coords">-116.2008</text>
  <text x="100" y="125" class="label">Loading...</text>

  <!-- Icons (positioned in wedge centers) -->
  <g class="icons">
    <use href="#pin-icon" x="100" y="40" />
    <!-- ... more icons ... -->
  </g>
</svg>

---

Document created 2026-04-26. Implementation to follow in dedicated session.